made of / made from

oversky

made of / made from 的用法应该算是常见的考题。
但是今天查 suit 这个辞，发现有的辞典是用 made of ， 有的辞典是用 made from。
是不是实用上并没有那么严格区分？

6 k+ Z+ ?7 O) Xhttps://www.oxfordlearnersdictio ... glish/suit_1?q=suit
8 g5 G& P/ b' X- s& _) Ia set of clothes made of the same cloth, including a jacket and trousers/pants or a skirt

4 b/ m% ~3 p; s4 O7 V; W5 @: ]4 q5 [https://www.ldoceonline.com/dictionary/suit
# T- a* L( U* la set of clothes made of the same material, usually including a jacket with trousers or a skirt

% e/ L8 L( M+ c# t8 o
https://www.macmillandictionary.com/dictionary/british/suit_2
a set of clothes made from the same cloth, usually a jacket with trousers or a skirt
7 d: J0 J) r5 r4 j' }' Z* X
+ a& c, Y) f. ~, P6 xhttps://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/suit
a jacket and trousers or a jacket and skirt that are made from the same material:

' i9 ]9 W0 f6 v2 r9 J: r

klwo2

看这个：https://english.stackexchange.co ... de-from-and-made-of

简而言之就是，有区别，可是区分得不严格，不遵守也没事儿

) }! x2 K1 p8 H9 f6 o- Z

elusty

4 J3 b# G: b% ?& H" F+ Fmade from 强调制造方式；
made of 强调物品的基本构成：Coach Shane专门有一期讲解了四个词：made of, made from, made out of, made with.
" Z! U7 ^" H! m" o" K* }他说，日常生活中，很多人是不分的。
  O( {6 m, I4 u& W3 y2 N我们平时说的是否改变形状和外观的from和of，他也提到了，是一个规则。
2 O+ u/ Y6 \* U7 `8 b
& N$ \3 O% e6 V3 ]- y& `剑桥：
Made from

We often use made from when we talk about how something is manufactured:

Plastic is made from oil.

The earliest canoes were made from tree trunks.

1 b0 J. U! a8 o3 a
9 `9 P0 Y) a' T' hMade of
" O4 a1 |$ \. @

We use made of when we talk about the basic material or qualities of something. It has a meaning similar to ‘composed of’:

She wore a beautiful necklace made of silver.

; a8 x: @0 T/ m/ A/ T

3 Y" X: e; a- P4 `& m- D6 Y0 _3 a

freecomic101

葛传椝英语惯用法词典 make 词条

* L3 e2 a/ f, t' S+ f  |

4. 说“把（原料）做成（东西）”，假使那原料并不变化得看不出原料，那表示原料的词的前面用 of，否则用 from，如 We make tables of wood 和 We make paper from rags。木材做成了桌子仍旧看得出是木材，但破布做成了纸便看不出是破布了。这里所说的“变化得看不出原料”，仔细想来，没有绝对的标准，如把面粉做成了馒头，不能断定是否“变化得看不出原料”，在这种情形用 of 或 from 都可以。  
; D* @0 T* k) J1 O" [不用 of 或 from 而用 out of，便加重了语气。

cocowind

5 g0 U1 o, Z7 b

  k5 N( d" f( aMichael Swan_牛津英语用法指南（新版）_斯旺著_外语教学与研究出版社_2010


" {  j* r" u% k5 Y

wpa

elusty 发表于 2019-7-1 20:29
made from 强调制造方式；
* E: V  r0 k/ t& M6 J8 K# zmade of 强调物品的基本构成：Coach Shane专门有一期讲解了四个词：made of, mad ...

3 W  W+ @0 \1 n0 b* j我也看CS 的，这个是在口语的那块，还是听力的那块？

elusty

wpa 发表于 2019-7-2 15:23
我也看CS 的，这个是在口语的那块，还是听力的那块？

& N6 e7 R( c. ~! k: m% P我是在油管上看到的：https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UAc5yO9ONIA
: O. T( a( j# D& n; ~' N另外，还有他的博客：http://0english.blogspot.com/2012/12/ec1-quiz-answers-how-to-use-made-of.html

: f% r1 H6 U1 Y* g0 q///////////////////
1 r2 h5 W( y1 G' NThe week's challenge was HOW TO USE:
. K2 n( c) |( u
; J( a' o- z5 y  ]0 K9 y% _made of ~
made from ~
made with ~
/ `& Y4 h5 M5 G. n, c2 smade out of ~
) ?" n1 S9 C7 p4 D- ]  L& K
) G4 _  R) ~8 d9 n& W# qThe answer: Most native English speakers do NOT distinguish. We mix them up. BUT, there are some rules:

  n# x' H7 F% z3 m
Made of ~ does not change form (house—still bricks, shirt—still cotton)
9 M: v4 l1 c' {/ y3 d1 R1 S; }Made from ~ changes form (paper from trees, wine from grapes)  
! {6 C* C+ N' W- E% J- P                     (cannot reconstitute--cannot go back to trees/grapes)
8 w( x2 x! q8 o, E8 B9 RMade with ~ care/love/meaning OR a mixture (A cake is made with eggs,
                     flour, butter, sugar)
Made out of ~ the source (especially ONE source/ingredient)—
                     wine/cotton/plastic/wood. My remote control is made out of
# d# ?5 R6 b5 X' H1 |* `                     plastic.
% F9 c0 i% u+ M* ?
  n9 S% X$ ~( |; f# R" v9 O
; r. i' X: j) p1 h* T" ^7 F
. k0 S4 P. G3 M8 }. o* FIt's a little confusing. And in most situations, more than one answer is possible. But NOT always!
5 _% n& x$ H' v
8 {/ W2 F, L, GThe answers to the QUIZ at the end of the video:  I have chosen the BEST answer first^^
  @2 c; D6 s& [" ]7 q) o2 B5 Y: ~

1. Orange juice is made out of oranges.  (Also "from" is possible.)

9 ^3 c6 Q) b+ x, b& O, v# ^

8 [6 P" w* g. W$ x+ w. o! H2. This house is made of wood. ("out of" and "with" are also possible)

$ Y4 T0 l! F8 e2 W9 ^

2 U5 v( Z& A" N/ I1 m! F# s# ^  c" R3. This dress is made of silk. ("out of" is also possible)

* q# K9 c8 T- ?# j# X# _! v' E

1 c6 g) @/ c! q9 V9 x
, E& x, u" y6 I! W3 N/ a4. This house is made of trees. ("out of" is also possible)

* U) F8 G1 U6 e( e' y2 s8 t4 Q5. This soup is made with chicken.

( n4 h' G! T) `' {, b& I

6. This sandwich is made with cheese.
  T  r% j* K: N% ]

7 R- O6 @5 f$ u" k7 N7 S2 Q& C
7. This sidewalk is made from old tires. ("out of" is also possible)

: K* ^- H$ R# I1 j3 T8. This statue is made out of marble. ("of" is also possible)
# j  i" K" b( r$ j# R1 W. [( Q7 Q
! D; O' o  O) D% s0 I# @. Z

( X8 Z& b! |1 R' C2 k9. These Christmas cards are made with love.
7 A, {8 e4 R9 J/ a) y: t  O# G# i
8 a: i- F* o: y+ c: K7 N3 r: q7 Y

! e9 C4 |3 ?+ s$ R( s- U
8 D: L% L5 A* C, ?- `10. Ice cream is made with cream. ("from" and "out of" are also possible)

) t- s/ F3 g3 d7 j+ p