这句又跟字幕对不上。。

pda_xixi_wiki · 发表于 2019-5-7 21:07:57

本帖最后由 pda_xixi_wiki 于 2019-5-9 09:04 编辑

链接: https://pan.baidu.com/s/1PaUrl12G9KeFH0iI9qelEw 提取码: nb2m

这段话的字幕是
The demonstrations are spreading these demonstrations where protesters are besieging and in some cases taking over goverment buildings.

红色部分从字面上我就有点看不懂；然后听音频感觉字幕有点对不上，我听的是

The demonstraions are spreading. These the demonstrations...

好像更加说不通

大橙子 · 发表于 2019-5-8 11:01:38

我听的是 These are these demonstrations where protesters are besieging and in some cases taking over government buildings.

fellboy · 发表于 2019-5-7 21:30:53

The demonstrations are spreading. This leads demonstrations where protesters are besieging and in some cases taking over government buildings.

pda_xixi_wiki · 发表于 2019-5-7 21:40:18

fellboy 发表于 2019-5-7 21:30' k3 B) x' c, C. |7 [
The demonstrations are spreading. This leads demonstrations where protesters are besieging and in so ...

赞这样听起来顺多了！谢谢！

pda_xixi_wiki · 发表于 2019-5-7 21:44:17

fellboy 发表于 2019-5-7 21:30! \* z4 O9 L6 H0 Y
The demonstrations are spreading. This leads demonstrations where protesters are besieging and in so ...

不过，感觉这样的话，lead后面应该有 to 才对；但听不出来有 to ...

pda_xixi_wiki · 发表于 2019-5-8 11:25:24

大橙子发表于 2019-5-8 11:01
/ I" I) A: O1 m& M, w R9 K/ a# M我听的是 These are these demonstrations where protesters are besieging and in some cases taking ove ...

你这语义上说不通

trivialstuff · 发表于 2019-5-8 22:30:10

pda_xixi_wiki 发表于 2019-5-8 11:25" L- n6 ?$ {- l' I' l
你这语义上说不通

我赞同 @大橙子所给的版本，"these are these demonstrations" 这段听起来并没有 this 的短元音，而都是 these 的长元音。

btw，这句话没有问题... 比如：https://youglish.com/getcid/17654749/%22these%20are%20these%22

pda_xixi_wiki · 发表于 2019-5-9 08:23:50

trivialstuff 发表于 2019-5-8 22:301 a: w) F& l" R' V. O2 ^- j( b4 {6 I0 i
我赞同 @大橙子所给的版本，"these are these demonstrations" 这段听起来并没有 this 的短元音，而都是 ...

谢谢回复。若是 these are these demonstrations，这个怎么理解呢？是在强调这种demonstrations吗？感觉好拗口啊

trivialstuff · 发表于 2019-5-9 20:11:46

本帖最后由 trivialstuff 于 2019-5-9 20:25 编辑

pda_xixi_wiki 发表于 2019-5-9 08:23
1 Q# T6 Y# F2 a; ^ Q K谢谢回复。若是 these are these demonstrations，这个怎么理解呢？是在强调这种demonstrations吗？感觉好 ...

一家之言，仅供参考：

可能就是偷懒图个方便吧，these are these 说起来相对省力，也不那么啰嗦。
试比较：

these are these demonstrations where...
these demonstrations are the demonstrations/ones where...
' N/ _ p$ O z

似乎可以发现用 these are these 这种说法之时有个规律，说话人或多或少都会用定语从句或其他方式，在后面补充更多的细节。

these are these + n. + that/which/where/....
these are these + n. + V-ing...8 ~5 N3 p3 u2 y2 l3 k

		自动登录	找回密码
密码			免费注册

[语言求助] 这句又跟字幕对不上。。

本帖被以下淘专辑推荐:

相关帖子

点评

点评